Keller Williams Settles Batton Buyer Lawsuit for $20M — What Texas Agents Need to Know
The Headline
Keller Williams just wrote a $20 million check to settle the Batton homebuyer commission lawsuit — becoming the first brokerage to settle this particular case. For Texas agents, this settlement has direct implications worth understanding.
What Happened
On Monday, February 2, 2026 — almost exactly two years after KW settled the original seller-side commission lawsuits — the company announced it reached a nationwide settlement with the Batton plaintiffs.
The key terms:
- $20 million payment to plaintiffs
- No new business practice changes required (beyond what NAR settlement already mandated)
- Full release for all KW franchisees, agents, and teams from antitrust claims
- Applies to homebuyers who purchased properties listed on MLS during the relevant period
Why Texas Agents Should Pay Attention
Here's the Texas-specific detail buried in the announcement: For Texas homebuyers, the relevant time period starts January 25, 2019. That's the most recent start date of any state — meaning Texas has the narrowest exposure window.
If you're a KW agent in Texas who's been worried about personal liability from these lawsuits, you now have clarity. You're released from claims by any Texas homebuyer who purchased between January 2019 and when the settlement takes effect.
The Bigger Picture
The Batton lawsuit is the buyer-side companion to the Sitzer/Burnett seller lawsuits that rocked the industry in 2023. While both allege the same core claim — that NAR's policies artificially inflated commissions — Batton specifically represents homebuyers who claim they overpaid.
Still fighting the Batton lawsuits:
- NAR (National Association of Realtors)
- Anywhere Real Estate
- RE/MAX
Separate Batton 2 lawsuit (filed 2023) names: - Compass - eXp World Holdings - Redfin - Douglas Elliman - And others
KW's CEO Chris Czarnecki was direct about the motivation: "We came to the decision to settle with careful consideration for the immediate and long-term well-being of our franchisees and agents... It was a decision to bring certainty."
Translation: Fighting litigation is expensive and distracting. $20 million buys peace of mind.
What NAR Says
NAR isn't settling yet. Their response:
"We respect Keller Williams' right to settle these claims... NAR remains actively engaged in the Batton joint defense group, and we continue to defend our rules where questioned. NAR continues to pursue all potential resolutions, both non-litigation and litigation, to reach a result that is in the best interest of our members."
Read between the lines: They're keeping all options open. Another settlement could come, or they could fight it out in court.
What This Means for You
If you're a KW agent: Good news. You have certainty and legal protection now.
If you're with another brokerage: Watch what Anywhere, RE/MAX, and NAR do next. KW often sets the pace — they were also first to settle the seller-side lawsuits (for $70 million in February 2024).
If you're considering a move: This is a reminder that brokerage choice involves more than just splits and fees. Legal exposure, corporate strategy, and financial stability all matter.
The Uncomfortable Truth
The commission lawsuits aren't going away. Batton 1, Batton 2, Cwynar, and others continue grinding through the courts. Each settlement sets a precedent and pressures remaining defendants.
The real estate industry has already paid out over $100 million in settlements across these cases. That money comes from somewhere — and ultimately, it comes from the business model that supports agent compensation.
This is why understanding your value proposition matters more than ever. Agents who can articulate exactly why they're worth their fee will thrive. Those who can't will struggle as the industry continues adapting to the post-settlement world.
Bottom Line
KW's Batton settlement is significant but not surprising. They're buying peace and letting their agents focus on business instead of litigation worries.
For Texas agents specifically, the January 2019 start date means a relatively narrow exposure window. But the broader lesson remains: the old way of doing business is being legally dismantled piece by piece.
Adapt accordingly.
Looking for a brokerage that puts more of your commission in your pocket? Learn how RaiderX's flat-fee model works →